Presentation and course
Progressive systemic sclerosis occurs more frequently in females, especially during the peak incidence years of 30 to 55, where the female:male ratio may be as high as 12:1 (11). African American patients are affected at nearly twice the rate of Caucasian patients with disease often occurring at a younger age and more severe disease manifestations resulting in increased mortality (35). Initial symptoms can be vague and include Raynaud phenomena, malaise, and myalgias. For diffuse cutaneous systemic sclerosis, after the appearance of inflammatory and edematous changes, progressive skin fibrosis can occur, resulting in tight and painful skin involving fingers, proximal extremities, trunk, neck, and face. Painful tendon friction rubs are frequently seen and are a poor prognostic indicator for risk of disease progression. The degree of skin thickening may vary over 2 to 3 years. In some proximal locations, skin remodeling may occur and return towards normal as time progresses. Residual and severe skin fibrosis can cause permanent atrophic digit changes, joint immobility, and limited mouth opening. Subclinical visceral involvement may also be present at disease onset, suggested by esophageal reflux and radiographic pulmonary abnormalities. More widespread visceral involvement often occurs within the initial 10 years, including prominent pulmonary, gastrointestinal, cardiac, and renal complications. Motility dysfunction is the most prevalent esophageal pathology in patients with scleroderma (16). A generalized small vessel vasculopathy affecting small arteries, arterioles, and capillaries is characteristically proliferative and obliterative, thus, contributing to organ dysfunction. Cardiopulmonary complications are the leading causes of death. Prior to the availability of angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors, scleroderma renal crisis was a major cause of mortality associated with rapidly progressive hypertension and renal failure. Reviews have emphasized the multisystem nature and clinical complexity of this disease (33).
Skeletal muscle involvement in scleroderma is common; however, the prevalence can vary widely in published studies due in part to an absence of an established diagnostic criteria as well as overlap of scleroderma with the inflammatory myopathies (30). Objective muscle weakness is present sometime during systemic sclerosis in at least 80% and is usually multifactorial. Disuse and deconditioning are responsible in part. Over half demonstrate a mild, nonprogressive myopathy with slight elevations of serum creatine kinase and aldolase levels. Approximately 12% have a more progressive inflammatory myopathy. Inclusion body myositis has been reported rarely.
Patients may complain of muscle pain along with weakness, particularly if a scleroderma-myositis overlap is present. Autoantibodies such as the Anti-PM-Scl can help support the diagnoses of a myositis overlap. In a database of 9,165 scleroderma patients, muscle weakness reported by a treating physician was 18.9% in patients with limited cutaneous scleroderma and 33.5% in patients with diffuse cutaneous scleroderma (30). However, studies have varied widely in prevalence of abnormal manual muscle testing.
The scleroderma-myositis overlap is often part of the antisynthetase syndrome involving scleroderma-like changes in the lung as well as overlap with polymyositis and inclusion body myositis.
Clinically apparent neurologic involvement in progressive systemic sclerosis, exclusive of muscular involvement, is infrequent (probably less than 10%). In a systematic review of neurologic involvement in scleroderma, patients with limited cutaneous scleroderma were found to have epilepsy as the most frequent reported neurologic alteration (04). Cranial nerve involvement has been described, with third, sixth, and seventh nerve palsies having been described along with trigeminal neuralgia. Trigeminal sensory neuropathy is found in about 4% and is the most frequently observed focal neurologic problem (31). Trigeminal divisions II and III are involved in 65%, with bilateral distribution in 63%. Trigeminal neuropathy generally occurs later in the disease but may precede or occur simultaneously with other presenting features. The presentation of trigeminal neuropathy in association with Raynaud phenomenon may predict subsequent development of systemic sclerosis. Trigeminal neuralgia may rarely accompany the more common sensory deficits; trigeminal motor function is usually spared (31). In patients with diffuse cutaneous scleroderma, headache was the most prevalent neurologic symptom followed by cognitive impairment (04). Migraine headaches are more common than in rheumatoid arthritis or normal control populations and may be present in at least 30%.
Peripheral neuropathy has been noted in less than 5% (04), but most occur at a higher frequency that previously reported. Reduced vibration sense, reduced pinprick, focal atrophy, muscle weakness and decreased deep tendon reflexes are often seen. Comprehensive electrophysiological testing using electromyography (EMG) and nerve conduction studies shows distal sensory impairment in as many as 50%, usually subclinical. Both symptomatic and asymptomatic carpal tunnel syndrome has been identified, with incidence up to 67% for asymptomatic median nerve abnormalities on ultrasound imaging suggestive of carpal tunnel syndrome (04). Nerve entrapment has been detected, notably ulnar nerve entrapment and manifests as large and small fiber abnormalities in a non-length dependent fashion (04). Clinically evident sensorimotor axonal polyneuropathies occur infrequently, usually later in the disease, but may occur early or precede development of other symptoms (03). Brachial plexopathy has also been reported and thought to be a result of the scleroderma vasculopathy. A systematic review of the published cases with peripheral neuropathy and systemic sclerosis identified main risk factors as diffuse systemic disease, calcinosis cutis, and anticentromere antibodies (03).
Autonomic neuropathy may rarely cause symptomatic postural hypotension and gastrointestinal disturbances with features of dysautonomia. Electrophysiological testing has shown frequent autonomic abnormalities, usually subclinical, in up to 80%. Autonomic dysfunction probably contributes significantly to esophageal, cardiovascular, gastrointestinal dysmotility, and bladder abnormalities, and may also contribute to impotence (01).
Cerebral blood flow hypoperfusion abnormalities have been found in the majority of neurologically asymptomatic individuals. These findings probably relate to intracerebral microangiopathic processes, including cerebrovascular calcinosis, and correlate well to focal or diffuse abnormalities noted on cranial MRI, which are observed in over 50% of cases. These findings may also be related to mild cognitive abnormalities noted on neuropsychometric testing.
A rare, localized form of scleroderma involving the head (scleroderma "en coup de sabre") may be associated with symptoms such as headaches, seizures, or hemiparesis; it may demonstrate focal cerebral MRI abnormalities, including vasculopathy (28). In a retrospective review, cutaneous severity did not correlate with the severity of neurologic symptoms and imaging findings (08). Scleroderma “en coup de sabre” has been associated with orbital and intracerebral involvement leading to epilepsy and impaired vision (22).
Other limited forms or localized forms of scleroderma demonstrate neurologic involvement even less commonly. Isolated case reports have reported describing intracerebral hemorrhage; ischemic stroke; optic neuropathy; impaired eye movements; hearing loss; facial weakness; vocal cord paresis; tongue fasciculations; subacute combined degeneration from malabsorption and B12 deficiency; multiple sclerosis; myasthenia gravis; acute transverse myelopathy; compressive myelopathy from fibrosis, calcinosis, or atlantoaxial subluxation; compressive radiculopathy or mononeuropathy (ulnar, lateral femoral cutaneous, saphenous); mononeuritis multiplex; brachial and lumbosacral plexopathy; and lumbar radiculopathy (04). Whether these rare clinical events are direct consequences of the underlying pathological processes, indirect consequences, or coincidental associations remains unresolved.
Descriptive studies of pain in systemic sclerosis are very limited. Schieir and colleagues report that the pain symptoms were common in their study of patients with systemic sclerosis and were independently associated with more frequent episodes of Raynaud phenomenon, active ulcers, and worsening synovitis (40).
Neuro-psychiatric manifestations are all common in scleroderma. Patients complain of chronic pain and symptoms of depression and anxiety (04) and may exhibit behaviors not unlike patients with other forms of chronic facial or dental pain. They are often depressed about pain and disfigurement, physical function and social function, and may be candidates for psychologic intervention should be considered.
Neurologic and muscular complications of progressive systemic sclerosis are summarized in Table 2.
Table 2. Neurologic and Muscular Abnormalities Seen in Progressive Systemic Sclerosis
Clinical |
Percentage of patients |
Muscle weakness Mild nonprogressive myopathy Migraine Inflammatory myopathy Peripheral neuropathy Trigeminal sensory neuropathy Psychologic dysfunction |
80% more than 50% 30% 12% less than 5% 4% more than 50% |
Subclinical | |
Quantitative autonomic abnormalities Abnormal (diffuse or focal) brain MRI Quantitative sensory abnormalities Motor nerve conduction abnormalities |
80% more than 50% 50% 44% |
Prognosis and complications
The course of systemic sclerosis in an individual can be variable, ranging from minimal symptoms to death. Age-adjusted mortality for progressive systemic sclerosis is approximately 3 in 1 million; rates for women are two to four times higher than for men (33). Black women are more severely affected and have a higher mortality than Caucasian women. For all populations, 5- and 10-year survival rates vary from 60% to 70% and 40% to 50%, respectively. Factors adversely influencing prognosis include female gender; Black race; skin thickening of the trunk; cardiac, renal, or pulmonary involvement at time of diagnosis; heavy alcohol use in Caucasians; heavy cigarette smoking in the first year; and anemia, elevated erythrocyte sedimentation rate, proteinuria, or hypoproteinemia at the time of initial diagnosis. The absence of proteinuria, elevated sedimentation rate, and low carbon monoxide diffusing capacity has been associated with a 93% survival rate at 5 years. Patients with systemic sclerosis generally have a worse prognosis than those with limited scleroderma. Severe organ involvement, in those which it occurs, is usually within the first 3 years; the 9-year cumulative survival rate was 38% in those with severe organ involvement versus 72% in those without such involvement (33). Complications arising from renal, cardiac, and pulmonary involvement are the leading causes of death.
Pulmonary arterial hypertension, in particular, is an important cause of mortality in systemic sclerosis. Patients with interstitial lung disease and pulmonary arterial hypertension are associated with a high rate of morbidity and mortality (12). Although echocardiography is used as a screen for pulmonary arterial hypertension, right heart catheterization remains the diagnostic gold standard. Earlier treatment with new agents is associated with better treatment outcomes. Patients with simple myopathy have a relatively benign muscular course, characterized by minimal progression and waxing and waning symptoms. The muscle weakness of polymyositis progresses rapidly. The course of inclusion-body myositis is more indolent.
Scleroderma renal crisis is one of the most feared complications and can affect patients with both diffuse cutaneous and limited cutaneous scleroderma. However, prevalence has been decreasing with 10% of diffuse patients and 2% of limited cutaneous patients affected (43). Scleroderma renal crisis typically manifests as acute onset of moderate to severe “accelerated” hypertension and oliguric renal failure. Some patients may exhibit hypertensive encephalopathy and retinopathy.
Several studies have reported the association of systemic sclerosis with thyroid autoimmune disorders and thyroid function abnormalities; antithyroid peroxidase autoantibodies and ultrasonography should be tested as part of the clinical profile in systemic sclerosis patients. Females, subjects with positive antithyroid peroxidase and hypoechoic and small thyroid should have thyroid function follow-up and appropriate treatment in due course.
Clinical vignette
A 48-year-old woman was in good health until six months prior to her first evaluation when she began to notice excessive tiredness, general but mild muscle aches, and intermittent hand discomfort with mild purplish discoloration on cold exposure. Two weeks before evaluation she developed painless right face numbness.
At the time of the first evaluation, the general physical exam, including vital signs, was normal. In particular, no skin, joint, or vascular abnormalities were detected. Neurologic exam was also normal except for mildly decreased pin sensation in the second and third divisions of the right trigeminal nerve.
Initial laboratory evaluation of routine serum chemistries, complete blood count with differential, thyroid function tests, and serum creatine kinase were normal. Sedimentation rate was mildly elevated at 45. Testing for rheumatoid factor was negative; antinuclear antibodies were present at 1:160. Cranial MRI demonstrated a few punctate white matter T2 hyperintense foci bilaterally that were nonenhancing after gadolinium infusion. Magnetic resonance angiography of the extra- and intra-cranial vasculature was normal. Cerebrospinal fluid analysis was normal.
Over the next nine months the facial numbness improved, but her other mild symptoms continued. In addition, her Raynaud worsened, and sclerodactyly developed involving both hands followed by similar skin tightening of the proximal arms. Repeat antinuclear antibody testing was positive at 1:2560. Anti-RNA polymerase III and anti-topoisomerase I antibodies were present; anti-centromere antibodies were absent.
A diagnosis of systemic sclerosis was made.
Comment. Neurologic complaints, especially at the time of presentation, are uncommon in systemic sclerosis. However, trigeminal sensory neuropathy is the most common focal neurologic event that is seen. In addition, the early presentation of trigeminal sensory neuropathy and Raynaud phenomenon together strongly suggests the subsequent development of typical systemic sclerosis (31).